An invalidation of Special Relativity and the Hafele Keating Experiment

Special Relativity theory doesn’t permit the existence of any physical clock because Einstein knew physical clocks act differently in motion/acceleration and therefore any physical experiment is dependent upon the interaction of motion/acceleration on the physical clock and not merely his thought equations. For example, the Hafele Keating experiment used atomic clocks to test time dilation, yet if they were consistent with relativity theory, they could have used –

A thought clock, which is nothing more than a rate in the mind
Any clock that has the same properties as a thought clock
Any clock other than an atomic clock
An atomic clock
Any clock with any tick rate at all, just as long as it corresponds to some other local clock rate.
The clock on the plane could have been an atomic clock and the clock on the earth could have been any other clock at all.

In fact SR is such a badly formed theory that we are not to know if the clock rate is changing, or only apparently changing, or what clock is changing, or if any change really occurs at all and time dilation is merely a maths fudge to transform from one reference to another and thereby save light at c in all frames. Also there is no relationship given in SR between the clock rate of the moving clock and the clock rate of the stationary clock, for the formula of simultaneity has nothing to do with clock rates at all, but only motion between two clocks and the speed of light at c between clocks A and B.

In fact the Hafele Keating experiment was flawed right from the beginning because any clock rate on the earth and plane is not known to change within the experiment at all, simply because any change in times between the two clocks could be accounted for in the following ways –

1. Plane clock sped up and the earth clock sped up at a different rate
2. Plane clock sped up and the earth clock stayed the same rate
3. Plane clock sped up and the earth clock slowed down
4. Plane clock stayed the same rate and the earth clock sped up
5. Plane clock stayed the same rate and the earth clock stayed the same rate
6. Plane clock stayed the same rate and the earth clock slowed down
7. Plane clock slowed down and the earth clock sped up
8. Plane clock slowed down and the earth clock stayed the same rate
9. Plane clock slowed down and the earth clock slowed down at a different rate
10. Plane clock was random over the time of the flight and sped up and slowed down, and the earth clock sped up
11. Plane clock was random over the time of the flight and sped up and slowed down, and the earth clock remained the same
12. Plane clock was random over the time of the flight and sped up and slowed down, and the earth clock slowed down
13. Plane clock was random over the time of the flight and sped up and slowed down, and the earth clock sped up
14. Plane clock was random over the time of the flight and sped up and slowed down, and the earth clock was random over the time of the flight and sped up and slowed down
15. Plane clock was under forces as yet not understood and not included in relativity theory and the earth clock was under forces as yet not understood and not included in relativity theory
16. Plane clock was under forces as yet not understood and not included in relativity theory and the earth clock was not under forces as yet not understood and not included in relativity theory
17. Plane clock was under forces as yet not understood and not included in relativity theory and the earth clock was only under forces included in relativity theory

In fact its well known that pendulum do undulate with a period due to a cosmic force acting all over the earth. As this force is not accounted for in modern physics (other than the geocentric ether model), then the search for experimental evidence of time dilation was definitely flawed from the beginning because we don't know what effect this force has on atomic clocks.

See the following links for evidence and discussions on the periodic effect of a cosmic cause on pendulums.

http://www.allais.info/panarep/panawork.htm
http://www.allais.info/panarep/colowork.htm
http://www.allais.info/panarep/ozwork.htm


JM